You are currently viewing (Barbecue) Pecan Lodge | The Pitmaster Sandwich
Pecan Lodge | The Pitmaster Sandwich (Brisket, Pulled Pork, Jalapeno Sausage, Slaw, Fresh Jalapenos)

(Barbecue) Pecan Lodge | The Pitmaster Sandwich

The Pecan Lodge is closely identified with the growth of Dallas barbecue: in 2010, when D Magazine hired Daniel Vaughn to do its first barbecue rankings, only five of the 16 places listed were within Dallas city limits, with the highest-ranked one coming in at no. 9. Yet within the past decade, a number of highly-rated BBQ locations have opened within Dallas–Cattleack, Lockhart, Pecan Lodge, and Austin’s Terry Black’s opening up a Dallas location just last year. Of these, Pecan Lodge led the charge from its stall in Dallas Farmer’s Market and was the first to receive accolades: Vaughn proclaimed them as possibly having “the finest brisket in the Dallas city limits;” Guy Fieri and his show visited in 2012, and in 2013 Vaughn (by now BBQ editor for Texas Monthly) rated it as the no. 2 barbecue in Texas in the magazine’s quadrennial rankings.  
 
Since then Pecan Lodge has moved to a larger permanent location in Deep Ellum and given up its low number on TM’s top-50 rankings, but it’s still arguably the best barbecue in Dallas, especially given Cattleack’s narrow opening windows. My first visit to Pecan Lodge, nearly four years ago, was rewarding but had two notable mistakes: 1) we went as a group of six and should’ve gotten at least one order of The Trough (1 beef rib, 1lb of pork ribs, 1lb brisket, 1/2lb of pulled pork, 3 sausage links) since it was my only reasonable chance of sampling everything, especially the beef rib; 2) I took no detailed tasting notes other than, “the brisket was a little dry and the burnt ends were juicy.” Profound stuff there.
Pecan Lodge | Brisket, Burnt Ends, Collard Greens

Unfortunately, I can’t do much better than that this time around as my short time to Dallas meant one of either Ichigoh Ramen Lounge or Pecan Lodge would be for lunch and the other for my layover in Chicago.  Ramen seemed far less travel-friendly than a barbecue sandwich, though given that TSA selected the latter for special screening, it may not have mattered.

Regardless, I bypassed the line by ordering the Pitmaster from the bar and found its trio of meats–brisket, pulled pork, and jalapeno sausage–to be a terrific delight. No complaints about dry brisket this time, though I think prefer Terry Black’s rendition of jalapeno sausage because of its inclusion of cheese, which works especially well in a sandwich. But this minor critique aside, this was a terrific sandwich in large part due to the inclusion of: crispy cole slaw and pickles; spicy and peppery jalapenos and onions layered on top of the sandwich; and most of all, an oversized, buttery, brioche-like bun that held everything together even as I wolfed it down in a dark cabin rattling in the turbulent air somewhere over Indiana. (Rest assured that my meat tasting notes are from the bites I snuck in before packing up the sandwich)

So this is an incomplete review. But my time in Dallas, the Bon Appétit Restaurant City of 2019, showed enough to make me want to make a longer trip here sometime later this year, with sufficient extra stomachs in tow to explore each restaurant’s menu more thoroughly. Pecan Lodge will be on the list; this time, I will have the beef rib.
 
Rating: Highly Recommended
Items of Note: The Pitmaster Sandwich, Brisket, Beef Rib (probably)
 
Pecan Lodge
2702 Main St.
Dallas, TX 75226